Carhaul Contract: One Year Later

Carhaulers are voting on a second contract offer, a full year after the contract expired on August 31, 2015. And guess what? It still has concessions in it.


The biggest concession—changing the method of pay—has been eliminated, thanks to the decisive 87% “hell no” vote on Hoffa’s first offer.

The IBT’s “Q&A” for carhaulers actually makes the claim that they “rechecked the math” and figured out the employers were not telling the truth!  

In truth, rank and file power defeated that giant concession.

There are other improvements in this second offer, but the concessions still dominate members’ concerns. On a Teamsters United conference call in August, over 700 carhaulers heard leaders and members outline the problems.  

An even larger issue for carhaulers—and all Teamsters—is a leadership which cannot or will not organize in our core industries, and which staffs grievance panels with too many people who are in bed with the corporation on contract “interpretations.”

While the rank and file rejection stopped the biggest single concession, there are serious problems with the proposed contract. If you look at the union’s original demands, and the outcome, you see this is not 50-50 bargaining but employer-dominated.

  • Article 33 (Work Preservation) is weakened, to allow farming out carhaul work. The IBT argues that this is just 2% of business, but Fred Zuckerman points out that in a five-year agreement, that 2% of cancer could grow to devour union carhaul.

    Across the board, carriers want to become “logistics” operations, sending traffic to the cheapest means available. The IBT has allowed this in other contracts: up to 50% of UPS Freight line haul traffic is now nonunion, due to Hoffa’s concessions. That’s right, the largest, most profitable transport corporation in the world is allowed by Hoffa to farm out its linehaul work—so believe it, it can happen in carhaul.
  • Article 48 is weakened in this offer, to abrogate the 20% limitation when business has been lost. Another potential job-killer. And it is weakened to give more carriers more ways to keep drivers out all week.

  • Our union should be about solidarity. Drivers, mechanics, yard workers…Central-Southern, Eastern. Examination of the concessions in the East, the failure to bring mechanics up to market pay scale, these are issues for all of us. So is the change to require three days worked per week or lose health coverage.
  • Any raise is welcome, but an increase of 30c (just over 1%) will not even keep up with inflation.

The outcome of this second offer is unknown. The IBT Carhaul Division is sending the Director and their attorney to meetings to tell people that a No vote means a strike and a strike means disaster. Is that how to build confidence of members in our union?

Carhaulers are smart Teamsters. Many have analyzed the agreement, in discussions and on Facebook. Whatever the outcome here, they are about building Teamster power, with a solid contract and organizing our core industries.  

That will only come with a change in leadership of the Teamsters Union.

ed-nauman-150-sm.jpgHoffa Doesn’t Have a Clue

“Our so-called leadership in carhaul—led by Hoffa—doesn’t have a clue or plan for addressing the nonunion cancer in our industry. They made that crystal clear with how they negotiated this contract. We need a Teamsters United victory this fall to set the ship on the right course and get the membership mobilized to retake the power we once had.”

   Ed Nauman, Jack Cooper Transport, Local 299, Detroit


walter-yanicki-150-sm.jpgWe Need New Teamster Leadership

“We’ve seen a pathetic track record on winnable grievances over the course of the last contract. Officers on the panels must have gotten the green light from Hoffa to let the companies have their way.

“We have to put a stop to all this and elect Fred Zuckerman.”

   Walter Yanicki, Cassens—Niagara Falls, Local 449, Buffalo

Showing 1 reaction

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Matt Studd
    commented 2017-02-04 23:47:19 -0500
    Yes…Carhaul Leadership failed the Membership again! Both times, the Tentative Agreement received unanimous (or close to) approval by the Two-man Carhaul Committee.

    It is not surprise with such Leadership..or lack thereof of, our Carhaul Industry is being decimated.
    Decimated by failing to uphold our Contracts and rendering incompetent Panel Decisions. Failing to negotiate meaningful improvements or clarification to existing ambiguous Language and Provisions. Failing to conduct meaningful Organizing Drives amongst a sea of competing Non-Union Companies. Failing to listen to the Rank & File Members.

    The Members need and deserve New Leadership. New Leadership will like see the need to remedy the aforementioned failures!
Get Advice Join TDU Donate

Recent News

YRC Plans to Reduce Terminals

YRC management has announced they plan to reduce terminals from 384 to 320 by the end of 2020. In comparison, the combined Yellow and Roadway terminals that formed YRC Freight totaled 571 in 2009.

Support the TDU Black Caucus

UPS Teamsters in Philadelphia have overwhelmingly elected Richard Hooker to lead their 4000-member local union. Hooker is the third African-American to lead a grassroots insurgent campaign and win Teamster office in the last year.

View More News Posts