Judge Says Employers Cannot Give Absence ‘Points’ to Fatigued or Ill Drivers

Teamster grocery drivers have won a case with implications for commercial drivers in every industry. A judge has ordered Albertsons to pay nearly $200,000 in damages for issuing attendance policy penalty “points” to drivers who refused to drive due to illness or fatigue.

The Surface Transportation Assistance Act protects commercial truck drivers from retaliation, including firing, suspension, and blacklisting because they make complaints to their employers or the government about violations of commercial vehicle safety regulations, or because they refused to operate commercial vehicles in violation of commercial vehicle safety regulations.

Department of Labor Administrative Law Judge Christopher Larsen ruled that Albertsons violated the law by issuing disciplinary points to drivers because they refused to operate commercial vehicles while impaired due to illness and fatigue. Accumulated points could lead to a suspension or a discharge. (Read the decision issued July 29, 2022).

Judge Larsen wrote:

"Respondent [Albertsons] offers no defense for its previous practice other than its own ignorance of the law. Neither is there any evidence of record to show any of the Complainants were not, in fact, too sick or fatigued to drive....

“[Albertsons] misled Respondent’s employees and further undermined their trust. Even now, Respondent appears to see nothing wrong with having hidden its new interpretation of the attendance policy from the employees who are affected by it."

Judge Larsen ordered Albertsons to pay compensatory damages of $5,000 to two drivers and $10,000 to two other drivers who brought this case, and to pay punitive damages of $150,000, and to pay attorney fees. The judge also ordered Albertsons to notify its employees at the facilities where the drivers were employed of his decision.

The four drivers who stood up for their rights are Jim Davis, Brian Traister, Mark Soto and Mike Raziano. They are all experienced truck drivers, and the judge found all of them to be credible witnesses.

The drivers who stood up for their rights are members of Local 952 who work at the Albertsons Irvine Distribution Center in Irvine, California. Steward Mike Raziano spearheaded the case, with the support of other drivers who testified in the case.

“Persistence paid off. I learned my rights and wanted to share that knowledge with others. I hope this decision helps drivers everywhere,” said Raziano.

Albertsons Companies is a major Teamster employer, which also owns Safeway, Jewel-Osco, Star Market, Acme, and other grocery chains.

The victory has implications for commercial drivers who work under a point-based attendance policy in any industry.

The drivers were represented by Attorneys Paul Taylor and Peter LaVoie from Truckers Justice Center in Edina, Minn.

Paul Taylor will be presenting a workshop at the TDU Convention this October. You can find out more or register for the TDU Convention here.

A copy of the decision is available here. You can also order the STAA Handbook, published by TDU, which is a detailed guide for commercial drivers to enforce safety and protect your job.

Get Advice Join TDU Donate

Recent News

Stay Informed, Stay United, Vote Yes to Authorize a Strike at UPS

Read the latest Teamsters strike vote information including a letter from Sean O’Brien and Fred Zuckerman and a Q&A. Spread the word and vote yes to authorize a strike.

UPS Teamster Strike Vote

UPS Teamsters will begin in-person voting to authorize a strike if UPS refuses to negotiate a fair agreement before the contract expires on July 31.

View More News Posts