Arbitrator Waters Down 9.5 Rights at UPS

UPS drivers’ rights were watered down when the IBT lost an important arbitration decision on 9.5 protections against excessive overtime.

The Hoffa-Hall administration promised members stronger 9.5 rights. 

But after an arbitrator sided with the company in a case that deadlocked at the National Grievance Panel, UPS management is now claiming it doesn't owe 9.5 penalty pay unless it “continually” violates a drivers' 9.5 rights. 

The company is already taking advantage of the decision to stonewall and deadlock legitimate 9.5 grievances. 

Pro-Company Decision

Siding with the company, Arbitrator Paul Glendon seized on a single word in Article 37 and ruled that UPS did not owe penalty pay to a driver on the 9.5 list because his 9.5 rights were not "continually" violated. 

What does "continually" mean? UPS argued that management has to repeatedly, frequently or constantly violate 9.5 to trigger penalty pay. The arbitrator didn't accept management's definition, but he didn't offer one of his own either. 

Instead, criticizing the “inherent ambiguity” of the language, the arbitrator ruled only that a St. Louis Local 688 driver whose 9.5 rights were violated in a single week months after he got on the 9.5 list “was not continually worked more than 9.5 hours . . . by any stretch of any reasonable person’s imagination.”

Future 9.5 violations will have to be argued on a case-by-case basis.

In making his ruling, the arbitrator faulted Ken Hall for accepting the company’s verbal assurances at the bargaining table, instead of negotiating protections in writing.

Enforcing Your 9.5 Rights

Stewards and members need to be prepared.

The best way to win 9.5 penalty pay is to document repeated 9.5 violations and show management did not make a sufficient effort to get your workload under 9.5.

That means keeping good records and filing grievances whenever you work more than 9.5 hours three times in a week.

Read the complete arbitration decision.

Get Advice Join TDU Donate

Recent News

Webinar: Getting the Goods to Win Your UPS Grievance

In this webinar, you'll learn proven strategies to win grievances at UPS, and how to deal with retaliation from management. Review how to document your case to win a good settlement and be prepared if the case goes to panel. Register for the webinar on Sunday, March 16 at 12 PM ET / 11 AM CT / 10 AM MT / 9 AM PT.

Resources: Hunting Season and Your Rights at UPS

Peak season is over. But a new year brings new problems: Surepost chaos, production harassment, and petty discipline. Teamster members joined our webinar to learn tried and true strategies to protect yourself and fight discipline. Watch it here, then scroll for resources.

View More News Posts