The History of the “2/3 Rule” on Teamster Contracts

By Ken Paff, TDU National Organizer — As we continue to vigorously demand that the Hoffa administration renegotiate, we need to look to the future. We need a new leadership and a new direction. To make that future, we need to understand the past.

With their clumsy attempt to impose the largest Teamster contract by minority rule, the Hoffa leadership has proven beyond a doubt that their loyalty is to themselves and their employer friends.

As we continue to vigorously demand that the Hoffa administration renegotiate, we need to look to the future. We need a new leadership and a new direction.

To make that future, we need to understand the past.

TDU's Long Fight Against the Two-Thirds Rule

The “2/3 to reject” rule has a decades-long history in the Teamsters Union. TDU was formed in 1976, and immediately launched a campaign to get rid of it.  

In 1987, we won a big victory in partially ridding our union of “minority rule on contracts.”  Prior to 1987, the 2/3-to-reject was absolute: no matter how many Teamsters voted, it took 2/3 to reject a contract which the IBT leaders deemed a “final offer.” And old guard officials used it.

As TDU became active, more contracts got rejected. In 1976, carhaulers rejected their national agreement, and it was imposed by the 2/3 rule. In 1982, UPS workers narrowly rejected a sell-out contract, and it was imposed. In 1987, the Master Freight contract was rejected by 64%, and it was imposed.

TDU sued over irregularities in that vote. Ron Carey sued also. In 1987, the IBT leadership, with the RICO racketeering lawsuit brewing, knew that we were near to winning the right to vote for IBT leaders. Under pressure, they settled up, and changed the 2/3 rule.

We won the partial eradication of minority rule. But, like many victories, it was not a total win. Part of the rotten rule still exists: if less than half members participate in the vote. 

We won other contract rights for all Teamsters. In 1984, in the Bauman v Presser case, TDU won an injunction and forced the UPS contract ballots to be impounded, and a new vote was held. IBT President Jackie Presser tried to conduct a “quickie” contract vote, with no time for members to meet, discuss, and distribute leaflets on the contract. That’s how we now get a reasonable period to consider contracts.

The Return of Minority Rule on Contracts

Since 1987—31 years—no national contract has been imposed by minority rule.

Until now.

Even Hoffa has not used minority rule on contracts. In the last UPS contract vote, in 2013, 18 supplements and riders were rejected. Ten of those were rejected by less than 2/3, with less than half of members participating in the vote. The IBT renegotiated and re-voted each of them.

What changed from 2013 till now? Nothing, except Denis Taylor decided to impose his rotten deal. But the buck doesn’t stop with Taylor, it stops with James Hoffa.

Members demand renegotiation. Several International Vice Presidents are demanding a GEB meeting be convened to fix it.

Keep up the fight on this contract.

Know your history. Know who has fought for Teamster rights. Get involved—be part of making a strong and democratic Teamsters Union.

We have an organization and framework to do it: Teamsters for a Democratic Union (TDU). 

Related Articles

Fighting for Change at Teamster Conventions Past and Present

On June 25 some 1,700 delegates and several hundred alternates will assemble at the Paris Hotel in Las Vegas for the 27th Convention of the Teamsters Union. The majority of these delegates will be there to rubber stamp whatever Hoffa proposes. Many see the convention as a chance to party on members’ dues money. But hundreds of delegates will fight for changes to rebuild our union’s power and strengthen members’ rights—and history is on their...

Take the Teamster History Quiz

1. How soon after the formation of the IBT did reformers challenge an incumbent president? ___Two years ___Twenty-eight years ___Fifty-four years ___Eighty-eight years 2. Which Teamster leader was beaten and nearly killed by opponents? ___ Ron Carey ___ Pete Camarata ___ Cornelius Shea ___ Tony Provenzano 3. Which Teamster leader likened himself to a Roman emperor? ___Tom Keegel ___Jackie Presser ___Mike Ruscigno ___Dane Passo 4. Which are victories won by TDU? __ Stopped unreasonable rules...

Women on Front Lines of Early Teamster Reform

Before TDU won the right for direct elections of delegates, women and minorities hardly ever made it to the floor of the Teamster Convention. The Right to Vote helped that situation. As we look forward to building a movement that includes the voices of all Teamsters, TDU would like to take advantage of Women’s History Month to acknowledge some exceptional women who have fought for their sisters and brothers against the corruption of previous Teamster...

Corruption and the Fall of Jimmy Hoffa: An Inside Story from the Man Who Claims He Killed Hoffa

Review: "I Heard You Paint Houses": Frank 'the Irishman' Sheeran and the Inside Story of the Mafia, the Teamsters, and the Final Ride of Jimmy Hoffa. "I heard you paint houses." Those are the first words Jimmy Hoffa ever spoke to Frank Sheeran, who would become a top Teamster official in the 1960s and '70s as well as a hired killer for Hoffa and the mob. The words refer to the splatter of blood when...

Celebrating History in Minneapolis

On July 24th, Minnesota unionists and other social justice activists held a day-long celebration of the 70th Anniversary of the 1934 Minneapolis Teamsters Strike. In the summer of 1934, truck drivers demanding that employers recognize and bargain with their union shut down all freight and delivery traffic in and out of Minneapolis for weeks. “Flying squads” of picketers patrolled the streets, stopping all non-union deliveries. Business, supported by the local police, cracked down violently. Two...
Get Advice Join TDU Donate

Recent News

IBT Settles Lawsuit Alleging Discrimination

It’s been widely reported that the IBT settled a lawsuit with 13 African American and Latino organizers for $2.9 million. Settling the case avoids long, expensive litigation. What’s behind the lawsuit and settlement and what does it mean for our union’s future?

Fight Layoffs with Contract Enforcement

UPS executives and Wall Street investors are crying because the company made “only” $9.9 billion in profits last year. The company will lay off 12,000 full and part-time managers as a result. Unlike management, Teamsters can fight layoffs. Here’s how.

View More News Posts